Case Studies: Kimberley B.C.
Kimberley B.C. in winter.
"Climate change is real. How it is occurring is not the issue.The effects need to be looked at and addressed." ~ Mayor of Kimberley, Jim Ogilvie, June 2008
Kimberley was one of two communities selected to partner with CBT to pilot a year-long community learning, engagement and planning process on climate change adaptation. The city worked with the community to identify the range of potential climate change impacts they may face in the future, assess local sensitivities and develop adaptation strategies. Their project was built around three distinct phases: Learn, Share and Plan. Kimberley did not follow one specific methodology, but the CIG Guidebook was influential in their planning.
Lessons Learned
The following bullets reflect Kimberley's lessons learned about the climate change adaptation project in general. For more specific lessons and tips about particular stages of the process, please check out the "Lessons Learned" section included at the end of each stage of the process (e.g. "Get Started," "Learn about Climate Change").
- Undertaking a climate adaptation project is an excellent way to inspire and support long term thinking, visioning and planning for a community through the lens of climate impacts and adaptation.
- Read the Climate Adaptation Guidebook prepared by the University of Washington’s Climate Impacts Group.
- Make sure that you have at least two champions/strong supporters, and preferably more–ideally you want at least one on local government staff, one on council, and a couple from the community that are connected with key stakeholders.
- Focus on building local capacity as much as possible.
- The CBT’s experts can give a lot of excellent background and guidance to your process – talk to them.
- Tap into your expert advisory group often.
- Cast your net widely in terms of local/regional expertise – you may be surprised to find out some of the resources that are right under your nose.
- Read about the City of Keene’s process, the Federation of Canadian Municipalities’ Municipal Infrastructure Risk Project, and the "Clean Air Partnership’s Cities Preparing for Climate Change: A Study of Six Urban Regions."
- Make it clear to all core participants that current climate science does not have all the answers around future local impacts, and that the science is still relatively high-level and directional at this stage. Scenarios are a useful way to transcend this gap.
- Partnerships were key to the project’s success. CALP’s climate visioning work was enormously helpful in engaging and communicating residents and stakeholders, PCIC’s climate analysis provided important direction to the local discussions.
Final Report
Kimberley's final report showcases:
- An organic, community-driven adaptation process
- Recommended actions for adaptation
- Key learning reflections
- Useful background information on the community
- Adaptation planning and local vulnerabilities
Case Study: Kimberley (pdf 282KB)
Executive Summary, June 17 2009, Kimberley Final Report (pdf 923KB)
Kimberley's Final Report (low resolution format without appendices / pdf 10MB)
An unexpected Partner: CALP Visualizations
In the fall of 2008, the University of British Columbia’s Collaborative for Advanced Landscape Planning (CALP) received funding to do a climate change visioning study as part of Kimberley’s adaptation project. The purpose of the study was to develop digital visualization tools to help communicate climate change impacts, adaptation and mitigation scenarios to local residents and stakeholders. CALP synthesized considerable map-based (geo-spatial) information about Kimberley both now and in the future, creating an interactive tool in GoogleEarth that allows users to view different scenarios for the community using GoogleEarth’s capabilities to show landscapes in three dimensions. CALP also created information posters on Kimberley's priority issues that included two dimensional visualizations and descriptive background information.
The visualization maps are provided bellow under the headline: Resources Specifically Used in Kimberley.
For more information on Kimberley's work with CALP, see Kimberley's final report or contact Communities Adapting to Climate Change Coordinator at adaptation@cbt.org.
Cost
The project cost approximately $29,000, with $20,115 of in-kind time and $3,169 in other in-kind contributions. Note: This figure does not include CALP's work.
See attached budget and in-kind contribution tables (33.5KB)
Time Commitment of the City
Estimates below are based on time spent at workshops, in issue working groups and/or in steering committee meetings. Kimberley had four public workshops, four working groups that each met three times, and a Steering Committee (that included the city planner and economic development officer), which met once a month through most of the project.
- City Planner - 10 days
- City Operations Manager - 3 days
- Fire Chief - 2 days
- Mayor - 3 days
- Councilors - 1-2 days each, depending on availability
- Economic Development Officer - 2 days
Communication, Participation and Outreach Efforts
- City news letters
- Workshops
- Media interviews
- Web updates
- Media releases
- Presentations
- Surveys
Purcell Mountains near Kimberley, B.C.
Resources Specifically Used in Kimberley
PCIC Analysis for Kimberley and District of Elkford:
- Columbia Basin Summary - Oct 08. (pdf 8MB) Most recent version, addressing most comments/questions arising from previous version (still draft form).
Table of Information/Data requests to AC:
Note: Kimberley and Elkford collaborated on their data requests, creating a master list and dividing up their workload and responsibility for tracking down information.
General Kimberley Climate Data and Other Local Statistics
- MarysvilleWeatherSummariesto 2008.pdf 70KB- monthly summaries of temp and precip taken in Marysville since 1972
- Kimberley Climate Data - PCC 50 km DLY04 12.htm- link to all historical climate data from stations within 50 km of Kimberley
- Sullivan Hill Snowpack Data (1946-2008):http://a100.gov.bc.ca/pub/mss/stationdata.do?station=2C04 Kimberly Commuting 2006.xls 42KB
- Kimberley Statistics 2006.xls 226KB- includes a wide variety of 2006 census data, including income, local demographics, housing value, etc
Ecosystem Information: Forests, Pine Beetle Projections, Biodiversity, Plant Hardiness, etc.
- BCMPB v5 BeetleProjection Update pdf 246KB- provincial mountain pine beetle projections
- BCMPB v6 Beetle Projection Update May 2009 pdf 743KB - provincial mountain pine beetle projections
- MarkCreekWatershed-MPB-Aug 1 2008 Revised.doc pdf 164KB- hydrological implications of MP Blogging in Mark Creek watershed
- http://planthardiness.gc.ca/- national hub of information about plant hardiness and ranges - also working on related climate change projections
- ClimateChange&EcosystemTreeSpeciesDistributionBC.pdf 6MB- potential effects of climate change on ecosystems and tree species distribution in BC (2006)
- Impacts of Climate Change on British Columbia's Biodiversity.pdf - this is a literature review - published in 2008.
- Wildlife Diversity in British Columbia_Biogeoclimatic zones.pdf 4.8MB- the starting place...current BC wildlife distribution "pre-climate change" scenario
- Biodiversity BC Major Impact Climate Change.pdf 638KB- report of BC Biodiversity Technical Committee, May 2007: literature review, forecasts, id of data gaps
- Climate Change Impacts - Freshwater Fish Canada.pdf 570KB- provides a general Canadian snapshot of diminishing range of cold-water species
- Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Scenarios / CC and Forest Range Mgmt in BC.pdf- comprehensive resource as per title - published in 2008.
- http://www.ales2.ualberta.ca/RR/people/hamann/climate/index.asp?page=ecology- more information regarding Andreas Hamann's work on projected changes to tree species
- Balshi et al(2008) gcb 14-forestfire.pdf 673KB- a scientific paper looking at implications for regeneration of burned areas in light of climate change
- Climate Impacts Forest-Based Communities / CFSCaseStudy.pdf 6.6MB- methods for assessing biophysical and socio-economic impacts of climate change at scales relevant to forest-based communities
Tourism & Recreation Related Resources:
- Kimberley Tourism Website Stats.pdf 28KB- shows location of people going to Kimberley Tourism website
- Resort Recreation Change in EK-2006.pdf 1.1MB- report looks at how destination resort development is changing the landscape in EK
- Sensitivity of NW ski areas.doc pdf227KB, NWSkiAreas-fig1.pdf, NWSkiAreas-fig2.pdf, NWSkiAreas-fig3.pdf, NWSkiAreas-fig4.pdf, NWSkiAreas-fig5.pdf
- adaptation in the ski industry.pdf 226KB- a review of climate change impacts and adaptation strategies for the ski industry (2006)
- BC Snow Trend Report.pdf 404KB- shows historical snow pack trends for selected locations in BC, including Sullivan Hill in Kimberley
Human Health in a Changing Climate: A Canadian Assessment of Vulnerabilities and Adaptive Capacity (Health Canada, 2008)
- Cover_intro_english_low.pdf 270KB
- Synthesis_english_low.pdf 572KB
- Chapter 1_english_low.pdf- Introduction
- Chapter 2_english_low.pdf- Assessment Methods
- Chapter 3_english_low.pdf- Vulnerabilities to Natural Hazards and Extreme Weather
- Chapter 4_english_low.pdf- Air Quality, Climate Change and Health
- Chapter 5_english_low.pdf- The Impacts of Climate Change on Water-, Food-, Vector- and Rodent-Borne Diseases
- Chapter 6_english_low.pdf- Health Impacts of Climate Change in Quebec
- Chapter 7_english_low.pdf- Health Impacts of Climate Change in Canada's North
- Chapter 8_english_low.pdf- Vulnerabilities, Adaptation and Adaptive Capacity in Canada
- Chapter 9_english_low.pdf- Conclusion
- Glossary_english_low.pdf- Glossary
The University of British Columbia’s Collaborative for Advanced Landscape Planning (CALP) . CALP synthesized considerable map-based (geo-spatial) information about Kimberley both now and in the future, creating an interactive tool in GoogleEarth that allows users to view different scenarios for the community using GoogleEarth’s capabilities to show landscapes in three dimensions:
- Mountain Pine Beetle 12MB
- Fire 8MB
- Snowpack 5MB
- Flood 9MB
- Adaptation 8MB
- Low-carbon Kimberley 22MB
- Resilient low-carbon Kimberley (Green Ribbon) 12MB